Cooperative Law
This model seems to have lost steam in the last few years. Links are broken and there doesn't seem to be an independent web presence.
Cooperative law focuses on settlement. Like collaborative practice, in cooperative law there is an agreement among the lawyers and clients for a peaceful settlement—however, it does not require the lawyers to withdraw if settlement cannot be reached.
A leader in the development of cooperative law, the Wisconsin Cooperative Divorce website describes the principles of their agreement as follows: Both parties and attorneys commit in good faith to do the following:
*Cooperate by acting civilly at all times and by responding promptly to all reasonable requests for information from the other party.
*Cooperate by fully disclosing all relevant financial information.
*Cooperate by obtaining joint appraisals and/or other expert opinions before obtaining individual appraisals or expert opinions.
*Cooperate by obtaining meaningful expert input(e.g., a child specialist) before requesting a custody study or the appointment of a guardian ad litem.
*Cooperate in good faith negotiation sessions, including 4-way sessions where appropriate, to reach fair compromises based on valid information.
*Cooperate by conducting themselves at all times in a respectful, civil and professional manner.
Cooperative lawyers report that they prefer this method because they fear that clients will be pressured toward settlement by the withdrawal of their lawyers in the event of litigation, as in the collaborative model. Under this pressure, cooperative lawyers believe a client may accept a settlement that does not meet all of her or his needs. Some holistic lawyers offer either collaborative law or cooperative law and put the choice in their clients’ hands.
However, there is controversy in the collaborative law community about cooperative law. Many believe that the commitment to settlement from the beginning is critical to creating an atmosphere of trust and settlement. Beyond just the settlement of the legal issues, collaborative law has broader goals of healing and transformation. Without the disqualification provision as the incentive to stay with the process, the critics of cooperative law believe it would be too easy to exit the process and head for litigation. Critics argue that collaborative law is more holistic. It addresses the broader emotional, financial, and spiritual questions. They suggest that cooperative law limits the resolution to the legal issues.
Pauline Tesler, a leading authority on collaborative law, has said, "I have expressed pretty much the same concern and viewpoint about "cooperative" law . . . . so long as the distinctions are carefully articulated and the clients thus are helped to understand differences and challenges/benefits of service delivery options, the choice is theirs, with our informed advice and assistance. My concerns have arisen on the legal side when I have encountered writings that argue cooperative law is exactly like collaborative law except for the DA [disqualification agreement]. It isn't, at least not when collaborative practice is done at a "best practices" level that provides services that aim to help clients arrive at deeper resolution. Doing our best in the informed choice phase means clarifying the differences and choice points involved.
The Boston Law Collaborative, a Boston law firm focusing on ADR [alternative dispute resolution] practices, offers a Cooperative negotiation process in family, business, and employment cases.... In addition, members of the Divorce Cooperation Institute, a Wisconsin family lawyers’ professional group, use a Cooperative process in divorce cases. The bottom line is that the Cooperative process is highly adaptable, so businesses and their lawyers can readily modify the procedures for their cases. [See] http://cooperativedivorce.org. —John Lande, http://law.missouri.edu/lande/publications/Lande%20Cooperative%20Practic....
The following Cooperative Law case study was offered by David Hoffman of the Boston Law Collaborative: In this case, my client (Smith) and her husband (Jones) were divorcing after a 25-year marriage. They both wanted a collaborative process and seemed like exceptionally good candidates for one. They were involved in productive couples counseling to discuss how best to co-parent their younger child, and they intended to remain working together in a small business that they co-owned. They clearly respected each other and cared for each other a great deal, despite their decision to divorce, and they communicated effectively. They had considered carefully the advantages and disadvantages of a CL [Collaborative Law] participation agreement and decided on a CNA [Cooperative Negotiation Agreement] instead. The primary reason for their decision was that their funds were limited, and they feared having to hire new counsel. They also said they were very pleased with their choice of counsel and did not want to lose the opportunity to work with us. The five four-way meetings that were held in this case were among the most productive, collaborative, and deeply meaningful sessions I have had in 23 years of work in the area of family law. There were a few challenging issues, and one very challenging issue regarding the primary residence of their younger child (the older was in college). But the parties had enormous respect for each other, and the principles contained in their CNA supported their good intentions. At the final four-way meeting, my client asked if someone in my office could take a picture of the four of us, because she wanted it as memento of the good feelings that the process had engendered. (I have never, in the several hundred divorce cases I have been involved in, had such a request and I found it a rewarding reminder of the potential of cooperative negotiations.) Excerpted from: Cooperative Negotiation Agreements: Using Contracts to Make a Safe Place for a Difficult Conversation by David Hoffman. http://www.bostonlawcollaborative.com/
User login
Practice Design, Management, Marketing
Articles
- Make Prioritizing Simple
- What Can Law Firms Learn from "Firms of Endearment"?
- Making a Living as a Peacemaker
- EXTENDING THE OLIVE BRANCH: A Case for Conscious Business
- Getting Control of the Email Monster
- Time to design law firms according to values?
- Get More Done by Doing Less
- Marketing 101: Stake Your Claim and Be Open and Notorious
- Listening Means Business
Blog entry
Law and Creative Problem-Solving
Articles
Blog entry
- Q: Intentions vs. Obstacles: Story of our Lives?
- Frank Talk: Part 1 SURVIVING DISABLING HEAD INJURY
- Fordham Law School Presentation on Personality and Law Office Management
- Type Law Presentations for General Public and Attorneys
- PERSONAL PROBLEM SOLVING
- Frank Talk, Part II: HEAD INJURY- Caregiving/Receiving - The New Normal
- Judicial Process: Stage for Human Drama?
- heart and mind
- Cognitive Dissonance and the Heart--final chapter
- Peacemaking in Our Own Offices
- Encouraging Dialogue About "No Blame" Family Court Procedures
- The Practicality of Play
- New Law Firm Paradigm
- 30 True Confessions of a Happy Lawyer
News Feed
- CWRU <b>law</b> dean says <b>law</b> school is bargain, jobs are available; lots of other <b>...</b>
- <b>Law</b> School Is Worth the Money
- Pelham tries <b>creative problem solving</b> in committee
- <b>Creative Problem-Solving</b> Using Simple Machines
- Holscher-Schuster remembered as a selfless visionary
- Hey Solon High Students: Join A School Club!
- Wellesley Books events
- Richard Madden: In search of a little intellectual conflict
- Roundhouse Roundup: Johnson uses creative ways to get on ballots
- The Hardest Job Interview Questions&mdash;And How to Ace Them
- 3 Reasons The 3-Martini Lunch Could Fix the Economy, Improve Your Work and <b>...</b>
- Unused inventions get a crowdsourced creative spark
- Greater working memory capacity benefits analytic, but not <b>creative, problem</b> <b>...</b>
- Election letters: Aug. 2 edition
- New Attorneys Join McCarthy Fingar, LLP As Mediation Counsel To Mediation <b>...</b>
- New Attorneys Join McCarthy Fingar, LLP As Mediation Counsel To Mediation <b>...</b>
- Use the "Generic Parts Technique" to Boost Creativity and Solve Problems
- 22 Years Later, Time to Get Serious About the Americans with Disabilities <b>Act</b>
- Stanford Looks to Virginia for Its Next Dean
- Stanford looks to Virginia for its next dean
- Guest column: College remains great investment for the long term
- Intercare Insurance Solutions' David Duenas Named Top Employee Benefit <b>...</b>
- Work Skills You'll Need To Survive The 'Conceptual Age'
- TNT's fascinating 'Perception' will keep viewers guessing
- To Think or Not to Think -- A Tale of Two Platforms
- 'Perception': New TNT crime show will keep you guessing
- It's a balancing <b>act</b>...
- Adventure learning – Changing the world of online teaching and learning
- Camp Invention immerses youths in <b>creative problem-solving</b> course
- Immediate rewards for good scores can boost student performance
- Collaborative Divorce Proves that Breaking Up Doesn't Have to Be <b>...</b>
- Camp Invention immerses youths in <b>creative problem-solving</b> course
- Talking works: UB professor develops method to analyze <b>creative</b> <b>...</b>
- Innovation is Key to Current Economic Climate, Institute Speaker Says
- Federal Crowdsourcing May Solve Problems Fast
- Cahill is picked again
- Iowa View: Celebrate USDA's heritage, land-grant legacy
- Talking works: UB professor develops method to analyze <b>creative</b> <b>...</b>
- Spain Lifts Ban on Hooker Advertising
- American Portfolios Sponsors 2012 Adventure TEAM Challenge at Frost Valley <b>...</b>
- Teachers to get 2 percent raise
- Teachers to get 2 percent raise
- People & Places: Forestville claims top prize at Odyssey of the Mind finals
- TFPD elects new board members
- MARY KRAMER: Biz-labor cooperation needs to survive
- Destination ValeDIctorian: AHS grad to receive first-in-state honor
- Your Students, Your Schools -- Ankeny
- Funniest/Most Insightful Comments Of The Week At Techdirt
- How Project Management Adds Value To E-Discovery
- State Rep. Could Be Pence's Running Mate Pick
- DIRECTOR, FINANCE, <b>LAW</b>, ACCOUNTING AND TAXATION (#20093495)
- Complex Commercial Litigation Duo Joins Crowell & Moring, Boosts New York <b>...</b>
- Berenson & Company to Name Jeffrey Sechrest as President
- Full-day kindergarten should be universal
- NFI pump 1.4m NOK into Oliver & Spike: Dimension Jumpers
- Can Drinking Make Men Smarter?
- Human rights could land MPs in the dock
- What the Founding Fathers really did
- Can Beer Solve Your Problems?
- Edwardsport agreement puts permanent cap on project costs
- State Courts Weather the Storm
- Originalist Sin
- Study suggests moderate drinking may stir creative thinking
- Pak youth determined to lead nation
- Letters, Week of April 26, 2012
- UIC study: Beer makes men smarter
- Eureka Search and Rescue: 10 Years Leading the Charge
- Was beer the secret to Facebook's success?
- Beer Bloggles - Your Brain on Beer
- Bottoms Up: The Ballmer Peak Is Real, Study Says
- Drinking Alcohol May Make You Creative, But Also Drunk
- School Board Candidate: Syndi White
- Drinking makes you smarter
- 'Happily unmarried'
- Senior Director Finance and Operations
- Graffiti issue requires some <b>creative problem solving</b>
- Collaborative <b>law</b> nears maturity
- Eureka teams excel in problem-solving
- UPI NewsTrack Science and Technology News
- Election 2012: Jan Adams for Ward 2
- 4 new IT outsourcing pricing models gain popularity
- 24 teams statewide participate in Destination ImagiNation
- The Prescott Companies Hosts “The Art of Fine Community Management”
- Health Highlights: April 13, 2012
- Drinking Alcohol May Make You <b>Creative</b>, But Also Drunk
- Bottoms Up: The Ballmer Peak Is Real, Study Says
- UIC study: Beer makes men smarter
- Beer Boosts <b>Problem</b>-<b>Solving</b> Skills; Women and Children Aren't First
- Can alcohol make men smarter? Study suggests yes
- Drinking makes you smarter
- UPI NewsTrack Science and Technology News
- Tactical Magic Design Featured in Textbook
- HCBC partners with Product Development & Management Association
- Savannah's business calendar
- Holding Hope: Validating By Cheerleading
- This year's last day for Seattle Public Schools: June 22nd
- Taking notes
- Taking notes
- Amazing Amputees and Limb Loss Awareness Month
- Graffiti issue requires some <b>creative problem solving</b>
- Directors Make Their Mark At SXSW Fest
- Getting More From Every Day: Reigniting Your <b>Creative</b> Fire
- Election 2012: Jan Adams for Ward 2
- Parramatta Marist Wins International Recognition for Innovative <b>...</b>
- Parramatta Marist Wins International Recognition for Innovative <b>...</b>
- On Stage: Seussical, Yankees, Tenor & Lots of Music
- How to effectively respond to mistakes
- 10 Questions: Irvington Candidate Mark Gilliland
- News - it@cork "Inspiring the Future" with Bill Liao Coder dojo <b>...</b>
- It's Time to Laugh It Up at the Theater
- Questions to Ridgway mayoral candidates
- Pickens County news briefs
- The Fractured Art Of Innovation
- Right Brain Skills: Valuing the Attributes of the Emotionally <b>...</b>
- Dyson: From standardization to inspiration
- At a crossroads: annual lecture series presents its spring offerings
- New Aristotle learning kits for homeschool standardized testing
- PROFESSOR PROFILE
- Fort Myers <b>Law</b> Firm, Phoenix <b>Law</b> Announces New Partner; New Name
- SOMETHING SPECIAL: Gifted, talented programs change directions
- Eurotech, Ltd. Announces Anticipated Change in Management
- Mr. Carlos A. Contreras Appointed President, International <b>...</b>
- YPSILANTI: Shakespeare in prison program comes to women's facility <b>...</b>
- School Briefs February 3, 2012
- Oliver & Spike: Dimension Jumpers In Development
- OLIVER & SPIKE: DIMENSION JUMPERS
- The STEAM Camps Are Coming
- Davis Malm Appoints Attorney Tamsin R. Kaplan to Firm
- Davis Malm Mourns the Loss of Shareholder David Rapaport
- Scribblenauts Remix - You Don't Want to Miss It
- Online Piracy's Cure is Worse Than the Curse
- Davis Malm Congratulates Michael D. Weisman on Lawyers Weekly
- College diversity at risk
- Reclaiming talented high school dropouts
- Seattle-area film producers head to Sundance - Seattle Times
- Dan Forest would tackle education, immigration as Lt. Governor
- Designing for life
- Joshua S. Grossman Elected Shareholder at Davis Malm
- NTIA's New Year's Resolutions
- Why we need to let kids be <b>creative</b>
- Meet the 2012 Pillar Awards Columbus sponsors
- Ayer-Shirley PTO hits the ground running
- IURC Approves NIPSCO Electric Rate Settlement
- How Gov. Rick Snyder, UAW President Bob King broke impasse, led <b>...</b>
- Loudoun Writers: Q&A With Barbara Simpson Carducci
- Oregon land-use planning program is award finalist
- US Government Strongly Affirms ICANN Model and New gTLDs
- Do video games make children violent?
- Mother feels call of duty when son has a video game in his sights
- eMazzanti Seeks New Windows Network Engineer
- Amendment to Combined Synopsis/Solicitation - Contract Specialist
- Climate change comes to our National Parks
- Specialisation – benefit or burden?
- FRANKLIN QST : Stephen Covey Releases New Book: The 3rd <b>...</b>
- The 3rd Alternative Book Cover (Photo: Business Wire)
- Stephen Covey Releases New Book: The 3rd Alternative: <b>Solving</b> <b>...</b>
- Center for Innovation, Creativity, and Entrepreneurship at <b>...</b>
- Combating the Police Code of Silence
- Combating The Code of Silence
- Guest essay: There's a lot going wrong these days
- Workers vs Volvo: Wheeling in Industrial Dispute
- Inside #OccupyBoston: The Marches, Meditations, and Messages of <b>...</b>
- Keynote Address of Assistant Secretary Strickling at 39th Annual <b>...</b>
- Election hopefuls get a little testy
- New Research Into Power Of Mind
- Pam Patterson, art teacher, Fishweir and John NC. Stockton <b>...</b>
- General Motors-UAW agree on new contract
- Late Friday night, the UAW and General Motors reached a deal on a <b>...</b>
- Another censure? Really?
- UK HR Manager - Putney London
- Hamburg School District: Report to the Public
- Boston <b>Law</b> Firm Davis Malm Announces New Marketing Director
- Get involved: September business calendar
- Editorial: Students must remain top priority
- Inside the secret world of hackers
- Helen Pastorino Announces Office Re-Configuration for Pertria in <b>...</b>
- Madison Budget Cuts Could Mean Police, Fire Layoffs
- Review Helps Adult Children Care for a Parent in Their Home
- Taj Palace Dubai appoints new food and beverage director
- Everything To Help You To Understand Power Of Mind
- Tampa Attorney Bill Yanger Honored By Martindale-Hubbell
- Indiana-American Water applying to raise rates
- The Power Of Your Subconscious Mind To Change Your Life
- Chinese Innovation Is a Paper Tiger
- National Invention Program Was A Blast
- Effective ways to maintain your pet budget during slow economy
- 'Travel addict' comes home -- with a book's worth of stories
- Program fuels student creativity
- Good for You, Martin County, July 24
- Hikma Hosts national and international internship program
- Settlement Reached In NIPSCO's Pending Electric Rate Case
- Halifax County school board hopeful points to creativity, commitment
- Are Violent Video Games Corrupting Children? Supreme Court Says States Cannot <b>...</b>
- Don't Call Them Fuddy Duddies
- Illinois: The New Leader in Education Reform?
- Feeds for Google Alerts
- Video: Self-Reflection for Conflict Professionals
- A boy aged four is believed to be the youngest child in Britain apologising to its victim.
- Creative Lawyering Sites
- Problem-Solving in Law School Award Goes to Missouri
- National Law Journal: Recession Makes Externships a Sweeter Deal
- Solving Tough Problems: An Open Way of Talking, Listening and Creating New Realities: Review
- UK Ministry of Justice puts Community back in Community Justice