Problem Solving Courts and Other Court Innovation
[See also Therapeutic Jurisprudence]
“…What we are doing is a statement of our belief in the redemption of human beings. It is a pronouncement from those in authority to some of our least powerful and most ignored citizens that we care about you and want to reach out and help you: your lives and well- being are important to us. The truth of the matter is that this may be the first time in the lives of many of these people that someone is actually listening to them - hearing what they are saying and telling them that they care about them and what happens to them is important. You know, there is a mathematical equation that for every action there is an opposite and equal reaction. I believe this is also true in human affairs. We tell them we care about them and they begin to feel worthwhile. Some pretty important people (judges, lawyers, and others in authority) are telling them we don't want them to fail- they begin to believe they can transcend. ….”*
* Judge Herbert Klein, Senior Judge, Circuit Court for Miami-Dade County, credited for creating the drug court concept. Keynote Speech, “The Power of Connection: Fuel for Drug Courts”. 1996 Florida Drug Court Conference.
In our complex society, courts are increasingly being asked to address social problems that are not compatible with the traditional system of adversarial justice and punishment. Recurring problems - such as drugs, homelessness, domestic violence, child neglect and abuse, mental illness, driving while intoxicated - come before courts every day. Veterans returning from war zones return traumatized and often can't fit into society. Problem-solving courts attempt to address the root causes of crime by addressing the recurring problems which lead to the criminal offense.
In 1989, the first drug court was started in Miami, Florida and since then, thousands of problem-solving courts have sprung up across the United States and around the world. Problem-solving courts focus on treatment of the underlying issue rather than incarceration. For example, if someone writes bad checks to pay for drugs and is arrested, the drug court approach would be to create a structure of support to get the defendant off drugs. The defendant would likely be regularly drug-tested, required to attend a program such as Narcotics Anonymous, obtain housing and employment, etc. The support structure might include drug treatment, social services, and a whole team of resources. The defendant must comply with the case plan set out for him or her, often over a period of up to three years, or the case reverts to the punishment system.
Judges in problem-solving courts generally take a therapeutic jurisprudence approach whereby they see each defendant as a human being and recognize the role of the court as having opportunity for impacting lasting change. Many such judges become parental figures, meting out advice, enforcing consequences and cheering for success.
Proponents of problem-solving courts argue that there is a significant cost savings. Providing the support for rehabilitation increases the probability that the defendant will become a productive, tax-paying citizen. Opponents of problem-solving courts generally argue that they are soft on crime.
Mental health courts
The problem-solving approach is particularly poignant in the case of mentally ill defendants who may just need the proper medical care to live normal and productive lives. Studies have shown that a large percentage of incarcerated individuals have issues with mental illness.
Shannon Murphy in The Flint Journal noted that, "Statewide, it costs more than $130 a day to house someone with a mental health illness in a state prison, according to Michigan budget information." and quoted a local official as saying, "There are so many in the jail that when they are on their medications can be out in the community as productive members of society." [1]
Mental health courts versus incarceration
The Flint Journal article on mental health courts went on to note:
* To house someone with a mental illness in a jail, it can cost about $125 per day.
* It costs about $33 per day to send someone through Mental Health Court.
* It can cost about $130 a day to house someone in a state prison who has a mental illness.
* A day in a psychiatric hospital can cost between $500 to $1,000.
* On average, it costs about $5,500 annually per adult for treatment of a mental illness.
* Nationally about 56 percent of state prisoners and 64 percent of jail inmates had a mental health problem.
Excellent resource for more information: National Association of Drug Court Professionals: www.nadcp.org
Additional Resources from The Center for Court Innovation: http://www.courtinnovation.org/
New York Chief Justice Judith Kaye at Tenth Anniversary of Center for Court Innovation
Audio Podcast:
A New Court in California: A podcast interview with Judge Wendy Lindley, who offers a preview of the Orange County Community Justice Center. http://www.courtinnovation.org/Podcasts/wendy_lindley.mp3
Principles of Problem-Solving Justice: An examination of the six principles that animate problem-solving justice. The principles are based on the Center for Court Innovation’s experience developing problem-solving initiatives, an analysis of problem-solving projects from across the country, and feedback from leading practitioners. http://www.courtinnovation.org/_uploads/documents/Principles.pdf
History of Problem-Solving Courts
http://www.courtinnovation.org/pdf/prob_solv_courts.pdf
In California, they're known as Collaborative Justice:
http://www.courts.ca.gov/programs-collabjustice.htm
Resources from other sources:
Problem-Solving Courts - Resource Guide
http://www.ncsconline.org/WC/CourTopics/ResourceGuide.asp?topic=ProSol
Conference of Chief Justices and State Court Administrators - in support of problem-solving courts
http://cosca.ncsc.dni.us/Resolutions/CourtAdmin/resolutionproblemsolving...
Problem-Solving Courts: Justice for the 21st Century?. Edited by Paul Higgins and Mitchell Mackinem. Praeger, 2009.
Historical timeline of problem-solving courts:
http://www.nadcp.org/sites/default/files/nadcp/Timeline.pdf
User login
Content Related to Court Innovation & Problem-Solving Courts
Blog entry
- Courts and Divorce—a Marriage Made in Hell?
- Empowerment as a method of resolving legal problems
- Therapeutic Jurisprudence is so much more than just Drug Court!
- Therapeutic Jurisprudence, Restorative Justice and Bushfire Arson
- Solution-Focused Judging Bench Book
- The Courts are in Good Hands
- Hon Peggy Fulton Hora in Melbourne
- TJ in Brazil
News Feed
- Opinion: Criminal Justice Reform And Risk-Taking
- Want to Keep Kids From Skipping School? These Teens Have Some Ideas
- Rule of Law: Judicial bench provides neutral viewpoint in courtroom
- Rockefeller drug law reform put politics, science in sync
- A sense of justice: The devastating impact of legal aid reforms
- Reform that worked
- Study: Reform of NY's tough Rockefeller-era drug laws saves the <b>...</b>
- Report: Easing NY's tough drug laws saves money
- Report: Easing NY's tough drug laws saves money
- Experts Praise Use of Youth Courts in School Discipline
- 14-Year-Old Greenburgh Student Excels in Courtroom and Beyond
- Annual AZ <b>Problem Solving Court</b> Conference Held in Prescott This Week
- RI told to open new <b>court</b> to protect women, children
- S.A. District 6 candidate John Barfield
- County board tours facility
- '<b>Problem Solving Court</b>' coming to Prescott Resort
- The manchild is in crisis
- Steele Authors Legislation To Promote Rehabilitation
- After the Tide Recedes
- Youth <b>Court</b> Wraps; Welcomes New Coordinator
- NYers get community service at Sandy relief
- NYers get community service at Sandy relief
- A different sort of <b>court</b>
- Two NY Groups to Receive Grants to Help Reduce Crime
- DOJ Helps Communities in Distressed Neighborhoods
- Staten Island Youth <b>Court</b>: Teens get involved in justice system
- Teens to judge teens as White Plains youth <b>court</b> debuts
- Greenpoint Youth <b>Court</b> Graduation Honors Leaders of Tomorrow
- CITY OF NEWARK TO HONOR NEWARK YOUTH <b>COURT</b> PARTICIPANTS
- <b>Problem solving</b> courts
- Niskayuna native elected president of The New York Bar Foundation
- Microsoft fights child sex trafficking with research dollars
- New steps aim to cut S. Tucson jail debt
- Prosecutor's office receives training
- Former New York State Judges Join Experts in Calling for Juvenile <b>...</b>
- New Lake County courts program helps prisoners transition back to life
- <b>Court</b> in session at Portland homeless shelter
- Judge creates unique <b>problem</b>-<b>solving court</b> to help unwed parents
- A new community <b>court</b> dedicated to the homeless at Bud Clark <b>...</b>
- <b>Problem Solving</b> Courts to host Law Day fundraiser
- The New York Bar Foundation Awards $450000 in Charitable and <b>...</b>
- New <b>court</b> connects homeless, services
- Call for overhaul of system to tackle female offending
- Women's jail 'should be demolished'
- Report calls for closure of Cornton Vale prison
- Glendale judge leads national organization
- Drug <b>court</b> participants form own service organization
- Restraining Orders Fail Victims, So Why Does the Abuse Industry <b>...</b>
- Office of Justice Programs Weekly News Brief
- Teens are judge and jury in Brownsville Youth <b>Court</b>, delivering <b>...</b>
- Seattle community <b>court</b>: Leadership in action
- Circle programs coming to SW Health and Human Services
- A New Newark: Rekindling Hope with New Community Courts
- Prosecutor “Sets Record Straight” On Jail Issue
- Harlem reentry <b>court</b>: One parolee's experience
- Helping others
- Getting to the Root Causes of Homelessness
- Newark's Youth <b>Court</b> Hosts Delegation of Camden Youth
- Custer County District <b>Court</b> Held Thursday
- Child-sex-trafficking stereotypes demolished by new research
- Lost Boys: New child-sex-trafficking research demolishes the <b>...</b>
- Summit County starts Ohio's first felony DV cour
- Adams County drug <b>court</b> to try to treat offenders
- New calendar aims to streamline RI's domestic-violence cases
- Woodland Park magistrate is new county judge
- Faith and Spirits Bring Solace to a Grieving Mother
- Nostrand Ave. Cleanup Day Scheduled for Tomorrow
- Child support <b>court</b> sees more non-custodial women
- Greenpoint Youth <b>Court</b> Teaches Teens to Respect the Rules
- No, no, no.
- Crime and compassion
- The Multi-Site Adult Drug Court Evaluation
- Study says drug courts effective in reducing crime, drug use, but state has <b>...</b>
- Youth Courts 101: A How-to Video Primer and Manual
- In Judge Nikkia's Court, A Response to Teen Crime
- Drug Court Study Says They Can Cut Drug Use and Crime, Save Money
- Study shows courts can reduce substance abuse and crime
- Lawyer buys $1.6M Park Slope home
- Center for Court Innovation Launches New Site
- NADCP Posts Conference Schedule, Opens Registration
- National Drug Court Month: May, 2011
- A Guide to Working Effectively with Young Children and Their Families in the Child Welfare System
- Center for Court Innovation: Vivid Testimony of Evidence of Change
- Georgia Governor Stresses Need for Drug Courts in Inaugural Speech
- Drug Court Grad 10 years ago - Drug Court Prosecutor Today
- National Association of Prosecutor Coordinators Endorses DWI Courts
- Representative Paints Solemn Picture, Calls for More Drug Courts
- Drug Courts Share Stats and Success
- PA Supreme Court Chief Justice Calls for Veterans Courts
- Judges: Keep Drug Courts Open
- Budget Crisis Perfect Time for Community Court to Save Seattle $65,000
- The Tribal Justice Exchange seeks “Senior Associate”
- Archives of General Psychiatry: Better Outcomes Seen With Mental Health Courts
- Mental Health Courts Help Psychiatric Patients
- Florida drug courts not yielding expected savings to state
- Cowlitz County Drug Court is Expanding
- Center for Court Innovation Seeks MSW for Parenting Court
- Criminal Justice Conversations Podcast: Promise of Problem Solving Courts
- New Veterans Treatment Court in San Diego headed by Vietnam combat veteran
- Child support court saving money
- Veterans court takes a chance on violent offenders
- One judge's opinion: Treatment Courts Save You Money
- Beyond Drug Court Graduation: Will County Provides Follow Up Support
- Article: Procedural justice and the mental health court judge's role in reducing recidivism
- Wisconsin Mental Health Court keeping people out of jail, saving money
- Veterans court gets show of widespread official support
- The National Center for State Courts Website Makes Available Articles
- NADCP Announces Resolution Re Treatment of Minority Participants
- Uniform Justice: Veterans Courts on PBS
- KY Juvenile Drug Court Restored
- 15th Judicial District’s Drug Court Program Receiving High Marks
- Project Dawn Court: Philadelphia's Newest Problem Solving Court for Repeat Prostitution Offenses
- St John's County (Florida) Opening Juvenile Drug Court
- Article: Applying Problem Solving Principles in Mainstream Courts
- 13 Graduate from Family Dependency Court
- Kansas City MO Municipal Drug Court Receives $544,120 Grant
- New Mental Health Court Opens to Referrals in Cowlitz County
- Mental Health Court Likely Coming to Manhattan in 2011
- Se proponen reformas a la Ley de Justicia Alternativa del Tribunal Superior de Justicia del Distrito Federal en Mexico
- Juvenile Drug Court in KY to Close for Lack of Funding
- Foro-debate sobre el Enfoque Restaurativo y Reparador de la Justicia Penal Especializada en Nicaragua
- Special Circumstances Court To Be Launched in New Zealand
- Veterans Courts: newest breed of problem-solving courts in need of funding
- Free Drug Court Training!
- Idaho Pioneering Judge Moss Dies
- Tulsa Director, Rose Ewing, Named to National Drug Court Hall of Fame
- Prosecutors to be trained in drug court procedures
- NADCP responds to NACDL Critique of Drug Courts
- Ceremony honors graduates of Birmingham drug, gun courts
- Specialty Courts Credited with Decrease in Jail Population in New York
- Volunteers help Juvenile Drug Court participants gain GEDs
- Mayor Graduates from Drug Court
- ND Treatment Courts Celebrate 10th Year
- NPR highlights drug court solutions
- Recidivism Drops in Those Supervised by MH Courts
- Drug Court Conference Recap
- Drug Court: Emotional and Uplifting
- Veterans Courts Provide Coordinated Response
- Truancy Court Newsletter Launched
- Arbinger Hires Retiring Judge Memmott
- Veterans Courts: Philadelphia Inquirer
- Drug Court Videos Demonstrate Transformation
- Cayman Courts Graduate 17 More Rehabilitated Offenders
- School of Law establishes pioneering Mental Health Court Clinic
- Colorado Prison Population Declines, Drug Courts Cited as One Reason
- Lawmakers explore drug courts, savings to taxpayers
- Veterans Treatment Court Aims to Help Struggling Vets
- Promoting Criminal Justice Innovation-UK
- 24 years sober, lawyer blazes trail in drug court
- Drug Courts Need Intervention: Quinn
- Couple Kicks Drug Habits, Reunites Family With Help of Court
- San Francisco chooses jail over treatment
- Study Says Mental Health Courts Alleviate Jails
- Peggy Hora: Jail is only for the dangerous
- Peggy Hora: Thinker in Residence in Australia
- Drug Court Conference in Boston in June
- NY Times on Veterans Courts
- City's new Mental Health Treatment Court aims to reduce crime and recidivism
- Veterans Court in News
- Upcoming Problem-Solving Courts Symposium in New York
- Mental Health Courts in Nova Scotia
- Crime Report: Problem-Solving Justice: How Well is it Working?
- Veteran's Courts Expanding
- Mom: I got my son back (from drug court)
- AFCC Conference in Denver in June to Focus on Alienation
- Internship Opportunity at Center for Court Innovation
- Travis County Establishes Veteran's Court
- Cherokee Nation Strengthens Juvenile Drug Court
- Pratt Named Indiana Judge of Year
- Drug court weighs criticism with success
- New Use for Problem Solving Courts: Fathering Courts
- Drug Court: They're all winners
- Australian Law Report on P-S Courts
- Blog: Drug Courts after Twenty Years: What Next?
- Center for Court Innovation Recognized
- Drug Court Grad Gets His Life Back
- Maryland Problem-Solving Courts Symposium
- Report: America’s Problem-Solving Courts: The Criminal Costs of Treatment and the Case for Reform
- 4 teens celebrate new start as treatment court graduates
- Law Reform Commission Final Report on Court Intervention Programs
- Sativa Story Conclusion
- Annual Drug Court Conference Draws Hundreds to Lubbock
- New Guide on the Design, Function, and Efficacy of Mental Health Courts
- Minnesota Judge Retires
- Judge says jails, courts not enough to deter youths from a life of drugs, violence
- Tasmanian Supreme Court Justice has Problem-Solving Background
- Maldives Considers Drug Court
- Daily News Series Tells Story of Man's Recovery to Obtain Custody
- Wisconsin Veterans Court Launches
- “Meting out justice with sympathy”: The race for NY District Attorney
- Behavioral Health Court Saves Money but also "Right Thing to Do"
- Judge Hora's latest publication on future trends in drug courts
- "I used to be a criminal" says drug court graduate
- Veterans Courts Urged
- On Thursdays, Municipal Drug Court opens a new path to recovery
- Wichita Oks Mental Health Court
- Keeping veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder out of jail
- St. Regis awarded grant to implement Tribal Healing to Wellness Court
- Portsmouth Community Wellness Court graduates first class
- Juvenile Court:: "Transition, Education, Alter and Mentor - T.E.A.M"
- Link to On-Line Registration AFCC Reno
- Drug Court "Ho‘omaka Ola Hou” (“rebuilding lives")
- Drug Court allows participant to take control of her life
- Drug Court "no walk in the park"
- Center for Court Innovation New Publications
- Mental Health Court making a difference: Editorial
- Drug court keeps recovering addicts busy on road to recovery
- Drug Court Graduate Reunited With Child
- New Juvenile Drug Court in Lauderdale County, Alabama
- $500,000 of Government Funding Supports Law School Truancy Court
- Nashua Telegraph Series on Mental Health Court
- Juvenile Drug Court Participants Build Garden at Zoo
- Veteran's Court Offers Second Chance
- "What a Mental Health Court Should Be": Blog
- Veteran's Courts: Connection Sets Them Apart
- Problem-Solving Courts Workshop in Indiana
- Prosecutor to Pull Out of Drug Courts
- New Drug Czar to Address 2,500 Drug Court Professionals
- New Book on Problem-Solving Justice Released
- PA Senate Adopts Legislation on 'Problem Solving' Courts
- New Court Would Help Addicted Veterans
- Vancouver Community court doing its job: Oppal
- 60 repeat DUI offenders successfully complete treatment program
- Judge Hora Thinker in Residence
- Due Process Challenge Against Problem-Solving Courts Fails
- Center for Court Innovation Seeks Articles for Journal
- A Parent Talks About Juvenile Mental Health Court
- Juvenile Mental Health Court Focuses on Rehab
- Bruce Winick Testifies
- New Problem-Solving Courts, Graduations and Awards
- Judge Goes to Bat for Drug Court
- Domestic Violence Court Celebrates Success
- BC Community Court Judge Stanfield Dies at Age 57
- Judge Makes 180 Degree Turn on Drug Courts
- Louisiana Chief Justice's Problem-Solving Vision
- Drug Courts Expand in Kentucky
- Despite Controversy, Mental Health Courts Increase
- Phish Frontman to Celebrate Drug Court Anniversary
- Cayman Islands Celebrates Drug Court Month
- First of 10 juvenile drug courts starts work at Pine Bluff, Arkansas
- Judge Listens to Offenders to Make a Difference
- Accountability, Healing Served Up in Drug Court
- Medical College Residents to Expand Drug Court Effort
- Ventura County Prosecutor Pulls DA from Drug Court
- Treatment, Not Incarceration for Vets
- MN Chief Justice Praises Problem-Solving COurts
- Guam Opens Mental Health Court
- Recovery Act Grants Include Problem-Solving Courts in MI
- Family Drug Court Established in Gregg, TX
- NM Governor Richardson Takes on Prison Reform
- Drug Court Celebrates a Decade of Getting People Clean
- New Treatment Court to Focus on Veterans
- Mental Health Courts Save Taxpayers Money
- Salaries Funded for Northeast Pennsylvania Mental Health Court
- Drug courts save lives and money: Virginia Pilot
- Drug Court Opens in Preston County
- Successful SF Drug Court Threatened by Budget Cuts
- Drug Czar focuses on treatment, drug courts
- Florida Weighs Mental Health Overhaul
- Dismantling sentencing laws recommended
- Mental Health Court for Violent Offenders?
- New DV Court Example for Country (UK)
- Offenders graduate from SF drug court
- 2009 Problem-Solving Court Judge & Coordinator Workshop
- Flint Journal Editorial: As Others See It, Mental health courts deserve state funding
- Statistics Show Drug Court Works
- West Australia Expands Drug Courts
- Twenty Years of Drug Courts -- Results and Misgivings
- Second chance to offenders
- Wales Opens First Drug Court
- Op-Ed: The growth of specialty courts: It's a good solution for Alabama
- Drug Court participants build homes for homeless
- Judges worry courts could be facing cuts
- Ohio Mental Health Court Opens
- Brazil Recognized By ABA with Prestigious Award
- DV Court Launches Another 128 Speciality Courts in UK
- New York Among Others in Focusing on Treatment, not Toughness on Drugs
- Defender Argues Problem-Solving Courts Unconstitutional
- Judge Petitions to Stop Closure of Mental Health Hospital
- Retiring Idaho Judge Brent Moss Honored, Pioneered Problem-solving Courts
- Judge Will Support Drug Court in Retirement
- Special Health Court Proposed
- 10th Judicial Circuit recognized for productivity, efficiency
- Courthouse Named for Pioneering Judges
- Drug Court Leader at Carbondale, IL
- Drug Court Professionals to Meet
- Boozman Recognized for Pioneering Efforts in Drug Courts
- Louisiana Weekly Endorses Drug Court Candidate
- Circle of Healing
- Arkansas Drug Court Celebrates 10th Anniversary
- Putnam Judges Wants
- Nevada Supreme Court Justice Gives State of Judiciary
- New York Times Reports Judges Seeking Say in Sentencing
- Pending Florida Legislation on Mental Health Courts
- Devil's Lake, ND Court Approved
- Drug Court Graduation
- Public TV program examines drug courts in MN
- NJ Drug Court Graduations
- Scottish Mental Health Tribunals
- Cayman Islands Drug Court Celebrates First Graduation
- WV Judges: Drug court making a difference
- Oregonian Editorial Board Supports Drug Treatment Court
- Rusk County, TX Okays Drug Treatment Court
- Oregon: Stakeholders enter Memo of Understanding on Mental Health Court
- Drug Treatment Court Graduations
- 'Sin taxes' proposed to fund treatment courts
- Devils Lake, ND kicks off juvenile drug court
- Policy Brief Encourages Public Health Approach to Drugs
- Mental Health Courts Good Investment of Tax Dollars
- Juvenile Drug Court in Alabama "Promising"
- Decreasing Jail Population Tied to Drug Treatment Courts?
- Brunswick County NC Mental Health Court
- New Youth Mental Health Court Pushed
- Remarkable Transformation -- from loving crack cocaine to loving her baby.
- A decade after reforms, a smarter juvenile court takes shape in Illinois
- Center for Families, Children and Court Launches New Site
- Judge Metzen - Outside of the Box
- New South Wales Drug Court Celebrates 10th Anniversary
- Roundtable Discussions Focus on Problem-Solving Courts
- Judge Campbell to lead peers, started Ohio's second mental health court
- Center for Court Innovation Podcast
- Circular Courtroom for Restorative Justice Programs
- National Center for State Courts Announces Center for Elders and Courts
- The New Paradigm of Juvenile Justice: Boston, February 13
- Another Award for Judge Hora
Video
- Jon Memmott: A Peacemaking Career
- Judge Ginger Lerner Wren: Mental Health Courts & Repairing the World
- Judge Steven Leifman: Enhancing Public Safety
- Judge Jeri Beth Cohen: Do the Job Right: Make a Difference
- Judge Cindy Lederman: Using Evidence-based Practices to Help People
- Judge Tracy McCooey: Maverick in Problem-Solving Courts and Restorative Justice
- Judge Peggy Hora: Problem-Solving Judge